Johnny Varner was twice married. He and two of his Varner brothers all married Andrews sisters rs. The Andrews were Quakers, a close-knit group of worshipers who were against marrying "co ntrary to discipline," (e.g. outside the church). John's first marriage was to seventeen-yea r-old Irena Andrews in 1827. Irena must have loved Johnny truly, for she paid a high price f or their love. A year and a half later (march 24, 1829) Irena was "disowned" from her church . The young couple settled in Barnsville, Ohio, and raised a large family of twelve children , all born in Barnsville. Before the outbreak fo the civil War, Johnny and Irena moved to Li nn County, Iowa. Johnny served in the Iowa Infantry during the Civil War. Not long after Ire na's death in 1868, Johnny married Julina (last name unknown).