[Joanne's Tree.1 GED.GED]
1 NAME Herbert II Count of /Vermandois/
2 SOUR S332582
3 DATA
4 TEXT Date of Import: 14 Jan 2004
1 BIRT
2 DATE 884
2 PLAC Vermandois Neustria
2 SOUR S332582
3 DATA
4 TEXT Date of Import: 14 Jan 2004
2 SOUR S332582
3 DATA
4 TEXT Date of Import: 14 Jan 2004
[daveanthes.FTW]
I wish I was sure of every name in this file & that I didnt
need to know what you think :) hey, but always refining this,
So if you spot a place where Im just flat wrong please tell
me or someone I didnt go on out with, I do this file out of fun and wanting to know, but do not
respond to the 'know it alls' , that dont have manners.I dont
consider them Kin!
Thanks and Happy Hunting!
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMONDOIS
NSFX *
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMANDOIS
DATE 15 Dec 2000
HIST: @@N2290@@
GIVN Herbert Ii, Count of
SURN Vermandois
AFN 9G82-J4
DATE 28 AUG 2000
TIME 22:21:58
NSFX et Troyes
TYPE Book
AUTH Stuart, Roderick W.
PERI Royalty for Commoners
EDTN 3d
PUBL Genealogical Publishing co., Inc, Baltimore, MD (1998)
ISB 0-8063-1561-X
TEXT 188-38; 231-36
TYPE Book
AUTH Å or c:Weis, Frederick Lewis
PERI Ancestral Roots
EDTN 7th
PUBL Genealogical Publishing Co., Inc., Baltimore, MD (1999)
TEXT 50-18; 136-18
DATE 30 MAY 2000
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
DATE 5 MAY 2000
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
OCCU Ct of Vermandoisubject: Re: Burgundy, Gerberga, Manassas, etc.From: Matman <mat_man@@hotmail.com>Date: Fri, 23 May 1997 18:20:11 +0900Todd A. Farmerie wrote:> > addressed by Szabolcs de Vajay,
in _Annales de Bourgogne_(hereafter AB)> 34:154-69. As is typical of the author, when faced with twoconflicting> versions of a relationship (in this case regarding theancestry of> Gerberga, Queen
of Italy) he develops an entirely differentone. In> this case, he concludes that Gerberga was granddaughter ofLetaud,> daughter of his son Othon. The trouble with this, (and I realise you're not
propoundingthis personally) is that in this theory, Otto-William marries thewife of his great uncle:Letaud/Leotold etc |__________________________________| | Othon || |Gerberga
|| |Otto-William 2.m Ermentrude m.1 Alberic II of MaconVajay invented this Othon/Otto to explain why Otto II of Macon(Otto-William's grandson) calls Letaud his _atavus_ as I mentioned ina
previous post. But as the sources have Otto-William as the sonof Gerberga, there is no real need for this Othon anyway. > Here he again differs from ES, showing Geoffrey marryingfirst, the> aunt,
Aelis of Vermandois, daughter of Heribert II, and by herhavingThis would mean that Heribert II (d.943) had two daughterscalledAdelaide Adela/Aelis etc. We know one married Arnulf the Old ofFlanders
in the 930's, so any daughter of Heribert II who wasyoung enough to givebirth to Fulk the Black and co in c.970, could not have comefromthe same wife: one would have to invent another wife
orconcubine.K.F Werner mapped out the Vermandois family in 1960, and themajorityof historians have followed his version, including the ES, Ithink.Perhaps if the two theories, ie Gerberga dau of
Lambert, andGerbergadau of Leutaud/Leotold, are kept separate, it might be a bitclearer.The Lambert theory: (Bouchard, 'Sword & Mitre', Werner Die Weltals Geschicht, 1960)Robert m. Adelaide|Adela
m.1 Geoffrey m.2 Adelaide m1 Lambert | d.987 | | d.978/9| | |Fulk III Maurice _____|_________________ | | |Gerberga
Matilda Hugom1 Adalbert m Geoffrey |2 Henry of Semur|Alberic II 1m. Ermentrude m2 Otto-WilliamThe Letaud/Leotold theory:_________________________________| |Letaud/Leotold m.
Ermengarde Giselbert d.956| m. Ermengarde| || Robert 1m. Adelaide m.2 Lambert| | _______________|_____________ |__________| | | ||
Gerberga m.2 Henry m.2 Matilda || m.1 Adalbert m.2 Geoffrey || | of Semur || | |Alberic II m 1. Ermentrude m. 2 Otto-William || ____________________||
|Guy of Macon m. AelisI havn't included the idea of 2 Adelaide's daughters ofGiselbert,or Hugo of Chalons, Geoffrey of Anjou, cos of space: but itdoesn't make much difference. Matt
DATE 27 OCT 1997[Spare.FTW]
[daveanthes.FTW]
I wish I was sure of every name in this file & that I didnt
need to know what you think :) hey, but always refining this,
So if you spot a place where Im just flat wrong please tell
me or someone I didnt go on out with, I do this file out of fun and wanting to know, but do not
respond to the 'know it alls' , that dont have manners.I dont
consider them Kin!
Thanks and Happy Hunting!
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMONDOIS
NSFX *
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMANDOIS
DATE 15 Dec 2000
HIST: @@N2290@@
GIVN Herbert Ii, Count of
SURN Vermandois
AFN 9G82-J4
DATE 28 AUG 2000
TIME 22:21:58
NSFX et Troyes
TYPE Book
AUTH Stuart, Roderick W.
PERI Royalty for Commoners
EDTN 3d
PUBL Genealogical Publishing co., Inc, Baltimore, MD (1998)
ISB 0-8063-1561-X
TEXT 188-38; 231-36
TYPE Book
AUTH Å or c:Weis, Frederick Lewis
PERI Ancestral Roots
EDTN 7th
PUBL Genealogical Publishing Co., Inc., Baltimore, MD (1999)
TEXT 50-18; 136-18
DATE 30 MAY 2000
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
DATE 5 MAY 2000
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
OCCU Ct of Vermandoisubject: Re: Burgundy, Gerberga, Manassas, etc.From: Matman <mat_man@@hotmail.com>Date: Fri, 23 May 1997 18:20:11 +0900Todd A. Farmerie wrote:> > addressed by Szabolcs de Vajay,
in _Annales de Bourgogne_(hereafter AB)> 34:154-69. As is typical of the author, when faced with twoconflicting> versions of a relationship (in this case regarding theancestry of> Gerberga, Queen
of Italy) he develops an entirely differentone. In> this case, he concludes that Gerberga was granddaughter ofLetaud,> daughter of his son Othon. The trouble with this, (and I realise you're not
propoundingthis personally) is that in this theory, Otto-William marries thewife of his great uncle:Letaud/Leotold etc |__________________________________| | Othon || |Gerberga
|| |Otto-William 2.m Ermentrude m.1 Alberic II of MaconVajay invented this Othon/Otto to explain why Otto II of Macon(Otto-William's grandson) calls Letaud his _atavus_ as I mentioned ina
previous post. But as the sources have Otto-William as the sonof Gerberga, there is no real need for this Othon anyway. > Here he again differs from ES, showing Geoffrey marryingfirst, the> aunt,
Aelis of Vermandois, daughter of Heribert II, and by herhavingThis would mean that Heribert II (d.943) had two daughterscalledAdelaide Adela/Aelis etc. We know one married Arnulf the Old ofFlanders
in the 930's, so any daughter of Heribert II who wasyoung enough to givebirth to Fulk the Black and co in c.970, could not have comefromthe same wife: one would have to invent another wife
orconcubine.K.F Werner mapped out the Vermandois family in 1960, and themajorityof historians have followed his version, including the ES, Ithink.Perhaps if the two theories, ie Gerberga dau of
Lambert, andGerbergadau of Leutaud/Leotold, are kept separate, it might be a bitclearer.The Lambert theory: (Bouchard, 'Sword & Mitre', Werner Die Weltals Geschicht, 1960)Robert m. Adelaide|Adela
m.1 Geoffrey m.2 Adelaide m1 Lambert | d.987 | | d.978/9| | |Fulk III Maurice _____|_________________ | | |Gerberga
Matilda Hugom1 Adalbert m Geoffrey |2 Henry of Semur|Alberic II 1m. Ermentrude m2 Otto-WilliamThe Letaud/Leotold theory:_________________________________| |Letaud/Leotold m.
Ermengarde Giselbert d.956| m. Ermengarde| || Robert 1m. Adelaide m.2 Lambert| | _______________|_____________ |__________| | | ||
Gerberga m.2 Henry m.2 Matilda || m.1 Adalbert m.2 Geoffrey || | of Semur || | |Alberic II m 1. Ermentrude m. 2 Otto-William || ____________________||
|Guy of Macon m. AelisI havn't included the idea of 2 Adelaide's daughters ofGiselbert,or Hugo of Chalons, Geoffrey of Anjou, cos of space: but itdoesn't make much difference. Matt
DATE 27 OCT 1997[Spare.FTW]
[daveanthes.FTW]
I wish I was sure of every name in this file & that I didnt
need to know what you think :) hey, but always refining this,
So if you spot a place where Im just flat wrong please tell
me or someone I didnt go on out with, I do this file out of fun and wanting to know, but do not
respond to the 'know it alls' , that dont have manners.I dont
consider them Kin!
Thanks and Happy Hunting!
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMONDOIS
NSFX *
GIVN Herbert II Count of
SURN VERMANDOIS
DATE 15 Dec 2000
HIST: @@N2290@@
GIVN Herbert Ii, Count of
SURN Vermandois
AFN 9G82-J4
DATE 28 AUG 2000
TIME 22:21:58
NSFX et Troyes
TYPE Book
AUTH Stuart, Roderick W.
PERI Royalty for Commoners
EDTN 3d
PUBL Genealogical Publishing co., Inc, Baltimore, MD (1998)
ISB 0-8063-1561-X
TEXT 188-38; 231-36
TYPE Book
AUTH Å or c:Weis, Frederick Lewis
PERI Ancestral Roots
EDTN 7th
PUBL Genealogical Publishing Co., Inc., Baltimore, MD (1999)
TEXT 50-18; 136-18
DATE 30 MAY 2000
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
Count of Vermandois and Troyes.
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
OCCU Count de Vermandois ...
SOUR Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart says 880/90; members.aol.com/sargen3
says ABT 884, Vermandois, Normandy, France;gendex.com/users/daver/rigney/D0001
says 884; www.public.asu.edu/bgertz/family/d0000 ;
SOUR Americans of Royal Descent, Charles H. Browning, pp 11, 163, 467 says 943;
COMYN4.TAF (Compuserve Roots), p. 3 says ABT 943; members.aol.com/sargen3 says
23 Feb 942/943, St. Quentin; Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W. Stuart, p. 168
Count of Vermandois; Heribert II - 1CHARL.TXT (Compuserve); Heribert II
(Caroling) Count of Troyes - COMYNI.GED (Compuserve); COMYNJ.TAF says mother
was Richilde - NLP; Count of Troyes - Royalty for Commoners, Roderick W.
Stuart, p. 127;Count of Meaux and Soissons - p. 168; Royalty for Commoners
says mother was Beatrice de Morvois - NLP; www.rootsweb.com/gumby says mother
was Bertha de Vermandois - NPH
DATE 5 MAY 2000
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
TITL Final.ged
REPO
CALN
MEDI Other
DATA
TEXT Date of Import: Feb 1, 1999
OCCU Ct of Vermandoisubject: Re: Burgundy, Gerberga, Manassas, etc.From: Matman <mat_man@@hotmail.com>Date: Fri, 23 May 1997 18:20:11 +0900Todd A. Farmerie wrote:> > addressed by Szabolcs de Vajay,
in _Annales de Bourgogne_(hereafter AB)> 34:154-69. As is typical of the author, when faced with twoconflicting> versions of a relationship (in this case regarding theancestry of> Gerberga, Queen
of Italy) he develops an entirely differentone. In> this case, he concludes that Gerberga was granddaughter ofLetaud,> daughter of his son Othon. The trouble with this, (and I realise you're not
propoundingthis personally) is that in this theory, Otto-William marries thewife of his great uncle:Letaud/Leotold etc |__________________________________| | Othon || |Gerberga
|| |Otto-William 2.m Ermentrude m.1 Alberic II of MaconVajay invented this Othon/Otto to explain why Otto II of Macon(Otto-William's grandson) calls Letaud his _atavus_ as I mentioned ina
previous post. But as the sources have Otto-William as the sonof Gerberga, there is no real need for this Othon anyway. > Here he again differs from ES, showing Geoffrey marryingfirst, the> aunt,
Aelis of Vermandois, daughter of Heribert II, and by herhavingThis would mean that Heribert II (d.943) had two daughterscalledAdelaide Adela/Aelis etc. We know one married Arnulf the Old ofFlanders
in the 930's, so any daughter of Heribert II who wasyoung enough to givebirth to Fulk the Black and co in c.970, could not have comefromthe same wife: one would have to invent another wife
orconcubine.K.F Werner mapped out the Vermandois family in 1960, and themajorityof historians have followed his version, including the ES, Ithink.Perhaps if the two theories, ie Gerberga dau of
Lambert, andGerbergadau of Leutaud/Leotold, are kept separate, it might be a bitclearer.The Lambert theory: (Bouchard, 'Sword & Mitre', Werner Die Weltals Geschicht, 1960)Robert m. Adelaide|Adela
m.1 Geoffrey m.2 Adelaide m1 Lambert | d.987 | | d.978/9| | |Fulk III Maurice _____|_________________ | | |Gerberga
Matilda Hugom1 Adalbert m Geoffrey |2 Henry of Semur|Alberic II 1m. Ermentrude m2 Otto-WilliamThe Letaud/Leotold theory:_________________________________| |Letaud/Leotold m.
Ermengarde Giselbert d.956| m. Ermengarde| || Robert 1m. Adelaide m.2 Lambert| | _______________|_____________ |__________| | | ||
Gerberga m.2 Henry m.2 Matilda || m.1 Adalbert m.2 Geoffrey || | of Semur || | |Alberic II m 1. Ermentrude m. 2 Otto-William || ____________________||
|Guy of Macon m. AelisI havn't included the idea of 2 Adelaide's daughters ofGiselbert,or Hugo of Chalons, Geoffrey of Anjou, cos of space: but itdoesn't make much difference. Matt
DATE 27 OCT 1997