Church Baptism Registry. It notes they had "gone to America". These twins were baptised at the same time as James Gray in that period in the Registry when it was not being used (from 1845 to 1866). Does not arrive in US with his twin and parents so he may have died shortly after his baptism. However, he IS in the 1880 census with this family AND, it says he was born in Ireland, so either this is wrong and Irish Benji died and this is an American Benji born the year after the family arrived, OR, the Ship's manifest and the 1860 census are wrong, OR he did not make the trip with the rest of the family and only followed later, OR, they swopped names and called Barclay Benjamin (the main family name) because Barclay IS missing from the 1880 census!!
1880 US Census- age 19, Millbury, Worcester, Mass. laborer. Born in Ireland, both parents born in Ireland.
1910 US Census - age 48, West Baylston, Worcester, Mass, hired man, single, born in MA unknown abt parents.- living with Goodnow/Goodman family at 91 Fairbanks St. farmer-working out.
1930 US Census - age 69, Dodge Road, Charlton, Worcester, Mass, immig 1861, born in Northern Ireland, both parents born in NIR. not married. He has a middle initial "F".