Other researchers state: Joseph was born Jan. 9, 1657 in Donegalshire, Ireland. Joseph was in the protest of 1688 with William of Orange in the defense of Derryshire. He died Sept. 8, 1692 in Lifford Parish, Ballygoogan, Donegalshire, Ireland. His parent's were John Caldwell, Jr.and Mary Holmes. Jane McGhie died in 1740 in Ireland and her parent's were Alexander McGhie and Jane Milliken. Joseph and Jane had 9 children.