A newspaper clipping found in Lillie Mae Hottel Roberts family Bible written by a guest present at the Grand Golden Wedding Anniversary, 1 September 1879, of Sam Horner and Mary Leah Andrew states that there were five persons living who attended their wedding in 1849 who also attended the golden wedding anniversary. Brothers and sister of Mrs. Horner: the two Andrews, JOSHUA T. and Thomas and Mrs. Sallie (Andrew) Ollis. The guest present refers to Uncle Sammy (Samuel Horner) and Aunt Polly (Mary Leah Polly Andrew Horner). Family lore speculates that the guest present is Eliza Horner McPheeters.
1860 Federal Census, Posey Township, Washington County, Indiana, p. 417
hh 1998/198: Joshua T. Andrew, 45; Farmer & Miller; $5,000/$800; b. S. Carolina
Elizabeth, 44; b. Tennessee
James H., 20; Farmhand; b. Indiana
Thomas, 17; b. Indiana
Bennet, 15; b. Indiana
Samuel, 13; b. Indiana
Mary, 11; b. Indiana
Charles. M., 5; b. Indiana
Caroline, 2; b. Indiana