Click to expand/collapse all notes Click to expand/collapse all other details

Male Carl Butterfield Click to view Carl Butterfield in the family tree

Carl was born on November 14th, 1884 in Lincoln, VT (Twin?).1   Carl's father was Chester O. Butterfield and his mother was Mary Etta Shepard.  His paternal grandparents were Orrimel S. H. "Osh" Butterfield and Lucy Ann (Luthers?) Leathers; his maternal grandparents were Oliver Shepard and Phebe Bushee. He had a brother named Clayton Edwin.  He was the older of the two children.1 

1 phelps.FTW @ Tree #1353
Further sources/citations:
World Family Tree Vol. 4, Ed. 1 @ Tree #2812, 2812.ftw