b. probably Sandwich, Massachusetts or Plymouth, Massachusetts

d, probably Machias, Maine, Machias VR 1:10, published in Feb 1799 in vol.21, #1 of The Maine Genealogist, quarlerly journal of MGS, page 34

b. 1740/41 Mary Allen Phinney, "Phinney Genealogy: A Brief History of Ebenezer Phinney (of Cape Cod) and His Descendants, from 1637 to 1947" (Rutland, VT: Tuttle Publishing Co., 1948?)

probably Machias in part later set off as Machiasport in 1826, probably before 1800 as there was no female listed as being a part of Nathaniel's household that year.

Mary Allen Phinney, "Phinney Genealogy: A Brief History of Ebenezer Phinney (of Cape Cod) and His Descendants, from 1637 to 1947" (Rutland, VT: Tuttle Publishing Co., 1948)

Probably after 1850 in Machias, Maine.

In 1850 there is a Josiah Phinney 82y, residing in East Machias in the household of John and Susan Keller, Susan being the daughter of Joaiah and Sarah. He may be enumerated in the 1820 and 1830 US census and possibly in the 1840